How to Choose a Restoration Company, and the Red Flags to Avoid

What a Good Company Does on the First Visit

The first visit tells you most of what you need to know. A careful company is calm, curious and specific. Expect them to do these things.

• Find and confirm the source of water, or ask who fixed it.
• Map the moisture with meters, and often a thermal camera, well past the visible stain. Water travels under flooring and up walls.
• Name the water category, meaning clean, gray or black water, since that changes what can be saved.
• Explain the plan in plain words, including what gets removed, what gets dried in place and how many days of equipment they expect.
• Give you paperwork to read, including a work authorization and a written scope or estimate.
• Set a monitoring schedule, usually a visit each day to take readings and adjust equipment.

They should welcome questions and show you readings. Drying usually takes about three to five days for clean water when it is started fast. If a company cannot explain why a wall is coming out, or will not show you the moisture numbers, keep looking.

For mold, a good company talks about containment, fixing the moisture source first, removing damaged material and cleaning with HEPA vacuums. For fire, they talk about soot type, odor sources, contents and securing the home.

Certifications That Matter

The IICRC, the Institute of Inspection, Cleaning and Restoration Certification, is the main standards and certification body for the restoration industry. Its written standards are the ones most insurers and professionals refer to. The S500 covers water damage, the S520 covers mold and the S700 covers fire and smoke.

IICRC certifies individual technicians, and firms can become certified when they employ certified people and meet its requirements. Ask which people on your job hold which certifications.

A certificate shows training, not honesty. Treat it as a minimum bar alongside licensing, insurance, references and the way the company treats you. Certification is not the same as a state license. A company can be certified and still need a license to do rebuild work.

Licensing in Nevada, California and New York City

Licensing rules differ by market. Always look up the license yourself on the state or city website instead of trusting a number printed on a truck.

Both Nevada and California have free public license lookups on their board websites. They show whether a license is active, what type of work it covers and any disciplinary history.

In New York City there is no single general contractor license for homes. Home improvement contractors are licensed by the city’s consumer protection agency. For mold, New York State requires a licensed mold assessor and a separate licensed remediation contractor for jobs over 10 square feet, and the same company cannot do both on one job.

Emergency water extraction alone may not require a contractor license in every case, but rebuild work almost always does. Ask whether the same company will do both, and check the license that covers the rebuild.

Questions to Ask Before You Hire

You can ask these in a 10 minute phone call. Write the answers down.

1. What is your contractor license number, and what name is it under?
2. Which IICRC certifications does the technician on my job hold?
3. Do you carry general liability and workers compensation insurance, and will you send a certificate?
4. For mold or sewage, do you carry pollution or contractors environmental coverage?
5. Will you give me a written scope before work starts and a line item estimate?
6. Will you record moisture readings every day and give me a copy of the drying log?
7. How do you bill, by the insurer’s pricing, time and materials, or a fixed price?
8. What do I owe if my insurance pays less than your bill?
9. Do you do the rebuild, or only the drying and demolition?
10. Can I call two customers from the last year?

Good companies answer these easily. Hesitation on the license, the insurance or what you owe is a warning sign.

You also have the right to choose your own contractor in most cases. Your insurer may suggest a company from its network, which can speed things up, but you are usually not required to use it. Ask your insurer to confirm that in writing if you are unsure.

Red Flags That Mean Walk Away

Most restoration companies are honest. A few are not, and they tend to show up right after storms, floods and fires when people are most stressed.

• Storm chasers. Crews that knock on doors after a disaster, often with out-of-area plates, no local address and no license in your state.
• Pressure to sign an assignment of benefits on the spot. This hands your insurance rights to the contractor. Never sign one in a hurry at the door.
• Large upfront deposits. In California, a home improvement down payment is generally limited to $1,000 or 10% of the contract price, whichever is less. Anywhere, a huge cash deposit before work starts is a warning.
• Cash only or payment to a personal account.
• Offers to waive or cover your deductible. That usually means the bill to your insurer is padded, and it can be insurance fraud.
• Blank or vague contracts with no scope, no pricing and no company address.
• Scare tactics, like telling you the whole house is toxic or you must leave tonight, with no testing or readings to back it up.
• Promises that insurance will cover everything before anyone has read your policy.
• A mold company that also does its own clearance testing in New York, where the law requires those roles to be separate.

If you feel rushed, stop. A reputable company will give you time to read, even in an emergency.

Mitigation Now, Rebuild Later

Restoration usually happens in two phases, and you can treat them as two separate hiring decisions.

Mitigation is the emergency part. Extraction, removing wet materials, setting drying equipment, containment for mold and boarding up after fire. This needs to start fast, often the same day, so it is reasonable to hire a vetted company without collecting three bids.

Rebuild is the repair part. New drywall, flooring, cabinets, paint and trim. This is not an emergency once the home is dry. Take your time here. Get two or three written estimates from licensed contractors, compare them line by line, and choose based on scope and reputation, not only price.

You are not required to use the mitigation company for the rebuild. Some do both well, and one company can make scheduling easier. Others are drying specialists who subcontract rebuild work. Ask directly.

Before the mitigation crew leaves, ask for a final drying log that shows every monitored area reached its dry goal. That record protects you if mold shows up later and helps the rebuild contractor know the framing is dry enough to close up.

Step by Step

1. Stop the Source and Take Photos

   Shut off water or make the home safe first. Photograph the damage before anyone arrives so you have your own record.

2. Call Two or Three Companies

   Use the directory to find a specialist near you, and call more than one if you can. Ask the questions in this guide and note the answers.

3. Look Up the License Yourself

   Search the license on the state board or city website. Confirm it is active and the name matches the company in front of you.

4. Ask for Certifications and Insurance

   Ask which IICRC certifications the lead technician holds. Ask for a certificate of insurance showing general liability and workers compensation.

5. Read Before You Sign

   Read the work authorization in full. Cross out or decline any assignment of benefits you do not understand, and ask for a copy of everything you sign.

6. Confirm the Scope in Writing

   Get a written list of what will be removed, what will be dried in place and the expected equipment and days. Ask for daily moisture readings.

7. Bid the Rebuild Separately

   Once the home is dry, get two or three rebuild estimates from licensed contractors and compare them line by line.

Mistakes That Make It Worse

• Hiring the first truck that shows up after a storm. Door-to-door crews after disasters include unlicensed operators who disappear with deposits.
• Trusting a license number on a business card. Always look it up on the official site and match the name.
• Signing everything handed to you in the first hour. An assignment of benefits can give away control of your claim.
• Letting a company close walls without a final drying log. Trapped moisture is how mold starts behind brand new drywall.
• Choosing the rebuild contractor on price alone. A low bid that leaves out baseboards, paint or flooring prep often grows with change orders.

Where You Live Matters